The recent updates from the Google Play Store signal a pivotal shift in how cryptocurrency wallet applications are regulated. Developers aiming to launch their wallets are now required to obtain proper licensing, fundamentally altering the landscape of app publishing in this sector.

This directive aims at several significant regions, including the European Union and United States, establishing distinct frameworks that developers must navigate to gain access to the platform.

New Compliance Challenges for Developers

One of the central elements of this policy is that developers in the US now have to register as a Money Services Business (MSB) with the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN). This registration comes with rigorous obligations to comply with Anti-Money Laundering (AML), Counter Terrorist Financing (CTF), and Know Your Customer (KYC) protocols.

This presents a significant challenge for non-custodial wallet developers, as they are not currently classified as money transmitters under FinCEN’s prior guidelines. The implications of this registration could push many developers out of the market altogether.

The compliance burden meted out by these new regulations goes well beyond existing legal standards, raising serious concerns about accessibility for a range of non-custodial wallet options on the Play Store.

Analysts have raised alarms regarding this approach, suggesting that it could stifle innovation and drastically limit user access to non-custodial wallets, which are often favored for their security features and user control.

This new compliance terrain may prove challenging and costly for developers, potentially leading to a drastic decline in the variety of wallet applications available to end-users on Google platforms.

European Landscape: A Similar Dilemma

In the European context, developers face comparable hurdles. The new regulations require them to acquire authorization as a Crypto Asset Service Provider (CASP) following the Markets in Crypto-Assets (MiCA) regulations from their respective national authorities.

This licensing structure is designed primarily for entities that handle or hold custody of digital assets, effectively sidelining straightforward non-custodial wallets from obtaining necessary licensing. Consequently, only certified CASPs will be allowed to operate wallet services on the Play Store within the EU, further constricting market alternatives.

This progression mirrors the guidelines established by the Financial Action Task Force (FATF), which lays out frameworks for managing risks tied to virtual assets and their providers. While FATF’s guidelines are not legally binding, they considerably influence regulatory development at the national level.

This scenario has fostered a complicated environment that allows major companies like Google to impose compliance measures that far exceed basic legal requirements, motivated by the need to uphold a safe and secure digital ecosystem.

Interestingly, the FATF has recognized that even decentralized applications (dApps) can display some central control, further complicating the distinction between custodial and non-custodial services.

This uncertainty complicates the regulatory landscape, positioning developers squarely under custodial regulations, even when they do not control user funds directly.

Ultimately, the advent of these licensing prerequisites signifies a movement towards a model of “regulation by commercial enforcement,” setting a precedent that could redefine the cryptocurrency application market.

Image Courtesy of DALL-E; Chart Source: TradingView.com