Cardano community decisively rejects $5 million copper investment proposal
The Cardano network witnessed a substantial pushback from its community against a proposal aimed at investing approximately $5 million from its treasury into a physical copper venture. The initiative, known as the Cardano Strategic Copper Reserve, was put forth by Toto Finance, which sought to acquire and tokenize warehouse-stored copper.

Voting concluded on November 15, revealing overwhelming disapproval. The proposal garnered only a tiny fraction of support, with negative votes surpassing positive ones by a staggering ratio of more than 140 to 1. This outcome means that Cardano’s treasury retains the funds that would have been utilized for this investment, raising broader questions about the community’s appetite for risk when it comes to financing real-world asset initiatives.
Proposal Details and Voting Mechanics
Initially submitted on October 15, Toto Finance’s request asked for the release of 22 million ADA to perform the acquisition, storage, and tokenization of physical copper. For the proposal to proceed, it required the endorsement of designated representatives, known as DReps, alongside approval from Cardano’s Constitutional Committee. A minimum backing of 67% from the active voting stake was essential for treasury withdrawals.
Ultimately, DReps associated with around 2.86 billion ADA voted against the venture, while only 20.02 million ADA showed support. Shockingly, this meant less than 1% of the total stake actively engaged in voting stood behind the investment.
Approval from the Constitutional Committee also failed to materialize. A majority of three out of seven committee members rejected the proposal’s constitutionality, while the other four members abstained from voting. Consequently, without meeting the necessary governance requirements, the request lapsed without any financial transfer to Toto Finance.
Reasons Behind the Rejection
The community’s decision stemmed from various concerns related to financial risk, management fees, and the oversight of treasury funds. One primary objection highlighted the investment’s dual reliance on the price metrics of copper and ADA. The treasury aimed to invest its funds in ADA, yet the potential returns hinged on future fluctuations in the value of physical copper. Toto Finance indicated that for the treasury to recoup its original investment, copper prices would need to surge approximately 49%, assuming the dollar value of ADA was stable.
Additionally, the proposal outlined considerable expenditures for technology, management, execution, storage, and insurance, amounting to nearly 3.36 million ADA—roughly 15% of the requested funds. DRep John MacPherson, a vocal opponent of the proposal, pointed out the treasury’s vulnerability to price volatility in both copper and ADA. He further expressed skepticism regarding the allocated funds for Toto, despite acknowledging that the proposal was relatively transparent in communicating its risks.
The Cardano Foundation had previously expressed reservations concerning the investment structure, particularly regarding fund management concentration and essential safeguards that were yet to be established. With the rejection finalized, it remains to be seen how the community will navigate future investment initiatives tied to real-world assets.